[Dimis]

I don't fully agree David,
Anyone that has fixed anything should fix it to last more than "one mile".

I don't have vested interest either way, but questionable workmanship is inexplicaple!

That's what the evidence thus far is pointing towards.
That said i'm not say PE are liable, but unfortunately, I'd hesitate to handover my money to a business that operated like this.

I'll wait for Eric's final word before Ill make my mind up!

Ps: there's nothing wrong with remaining silent if you paid good money for that job! What do you have to sing about?
Now if I got a good deal... Then I'd sing, and most of do!