After reading a bunch of posts, it seems like the Avons are hard to beat for overall performance and a vintage look.
The Sportsman STs probably have the look you want and are reasonably priced. The Sportsman SRs have gotten some good reviews, but the tread pattern is different.
Another fun option that would be less expensive would be MT ET drag slicks. It's hard to tell, but I think they have white letters.
Mickey Thompson Performance Tires & Wheels
Most reviews on the BFGs are that they are rock hard and unforgiving.