Dave,
You asked what we think, I answered my thought. If you only wanted 'atta boys' you should not ask that.
I will tell you that when brake dust settles into the Plasti-Dip you will not like the look of an immaculate car with sad-looking wheels. Also it peels a bit with heat.
Sheldon-there's not right or wrong here. Just subjective.
And I'm
always right...