Either way at $30K plus or minus... How much could really lose over 5 years?
Ownership will cost you more than any loss you stand to realize on either purchase.
So with that in mind pic the one that you'd gravitate to first, if you were to see them parked next to each other.
Just saying, that would be my approach.
PS: If I had to guess the way you defended the Automatic - You like the Shell Valley better don't you?
