Thread: Misconceptions
View Single Post
  #197 (permalink)  
Old 09-22-2015, 09:17 PM
jhv48 jhv48 is offline
CC Member
Visit my Photo Gallery

 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Carlsbad, Ca
Cobra Make, Engine: SPF 2932 with 438 Lykins Motorsports engine. Previous owner of FFR 5452.
Posts: 2,616
Not Ranked     
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by moore_rb View Post
So considering your own assessments, taken in aggregate:

1: Agreeing that your continuation car is a replica, and now
2: Assessing your continuation car to be authentic

By collaboration of your own arguments, you thereby own an "authentic replica"... Exactly like every Factory Five owner on this forum....



Yes.... Probably easy for a Lawyer to understand; but I'm an Engineer, and a car-guy.

By the application of your same logic (That legal branding and trademarking is what defines the authenticity, or the "essence" of the automobile in question), you would imply that the Holden Commodore, which Bob Lutz brought over to the US and started selling in 2004, was in fact, an authentic Pontiac GTO...

Which it was NOT.... Not then. Not now. Not EVER.

Every "Authentic and genuine" Shelby Cobra was built and sold in the 1960's. You can debate that point all you like... but you can not replace canonical history, with legal interpretation.

All the legal posturing, all the condescending rolleyes smileys, and all the New Jersey dick-swinging, does not re-define basic realities.

and Reality Number One, is that your car is much a "Real 1" as every Factory Five car is...

Oh, and Here- Right back atcha....
Damn! A new kid in the playground! This is going to get good!
You can bet your last spinner that REALJUAN is typing his response as we sleep.
__________________
Jim