Quote:
Originally Posted by Nedsel
So, fifty pages later, it boils down to the definition of "replica" in the dictionary - "an exact copy or model of something" - versus a paragraph in the 2008 SAAC Registry explaining that many different copies of the "Cobra" had been built that were really nothing like the original, yet they were still considered "replicas" in peoples' minds. So, as stated in the registry: "This left the true replicas - like Shelby's CSX 4000s - to come up with another name to describe themselves. Because he did not want his cars devalued by using the term 'replica,' Shelby chose "Component Cobra." And the MSO - Manufacturer's Statement of Origin - for a CSX 4xxx-series car states that is is sold without an engine or transmission, so in fact it is a component car, i.e. sold incomplete.
It would appear to me that each of these factors suggests the real argument should be "Why does every thread devolve into a Component vs. Replica argument?"
|
Cute. Again someone taking quotes out of context and in this case statements that only partially state what the Registry says. From a Registrar no less.
I think you need to read more closely and maybe stick with classifying originals as "original", "original restored", "reconstructed" etc...and stick with the "Websters" deifinition of "replica" as used in your Clubs Registry. Perhaps your not familiar with the Webster's definition they utilized? See page 30 of the Registry. I'm sure you have one. There are numerous references in your club's Registry that make it clear the Continuation Cobras are not "replicas" and considered authentic Cobras.
Oh, btw, luckily Shelby's didn't continue production from 1968 onward or the "continued" production of 3000 cars would be "kits" under most DMV definitions and dictionary definitions. Imagine that.
Carroll chose the word "component" as it was needed to adhere to all the current Federal safety regulations and but of that need would not have used or chosen that term. See page 708 if you need help.
I'm good with "Current production Cobras" as defined in the Registry.