Hi Troy - those appear to be ERAs. They do seem to fit a little off. I don't have a good close up of mine but you can see how they fit here.
I take it you have not installed the Velcro strips in the wheel wells and the snap to the bottom floor pan yet to secure the lower flap?
Seems I remember that ERA had a running change in the rear flare and it may be they had to re-shape the spats a little as a result.