Thread: synthetic oil
View Single Post
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 04-22-2004, 05:23 AM
Bruce Edwards's Avatar
Bruce Edwards Bruce Edwards is offline
CC Member
Visit my Photo Gallery

 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Winter Park, Fl
Cobra Make, Engine: Hunter with a 4.6 supercharged
Posts: 690
Not Ranked     
Default

Ok I have to put in my 2 cents.
I have one question but it may led to more that that.
Has anyone seen a side by side wear test with conventional oil and synthetic? In all these years I have yet to see a true engine side by side test. Why is that? Can not be due to cost. How much would it be to hire an independent lab to have two identical engines run side by side? One running say Valvoline 20/50 and one running Mobil or Amsol or what ever in a 20/50. Change the oil when recommended by the engine builder i. e. Ford,GM or whom ever for the conventional and changing the oil when Mobil one or Amsol says to. Keep a cost list of oil change cost say up to the equivalent of 100,000 miles. Tear them both down and measure all area's of wear and post the result for all to see. If the synthetic is all that wonderful seems like I would have seen this years ago. I have had synthetic sales folks come to my shop to sell me the stuff and have asked everyone of them the same question as yet have never had an answer.
I have had customers that love their Mobil 1 and use it from day one after break in. Have one customer that kept the car for 12 years or more and bingo at around 125,000 she started burning oil. Never did get a chance to tear it down to check it for wear as his son wreaked the car shortly after it started smoking.
Till then I will stick to what I know works over the long haul.
If any of you have seen a test like I am talking about PLEASE tell me were to find it.
Old school what can I tell you.
Oh and just for the record I have never had an engine of mine come back for an oil related failure in over 25 years of building engines using the "old" stuff.
__________________
Bruce Edwards
Gemini Motorcars Inc.
http://home.bellsouth.net/p/PWP-GeminiMotorcars
Reply With Quote