My first inclination would be that your gauge is not reading accurately, because this is quite improbable. My
oil temp and water temp gauges and probes are the same so if you can put the
oil temp lead on the water temp gauge and see if you get the same readings. I would say you definetly have a problem if they are and I am not sure how to cure it, but I will try to research it. Let us know what you find out.