Will B,
Am surprised how the chassis numbers run...my #2027 dates to 97/98, and a few other FIA's I have seen that are years newer had much higher numbers, go figure. They saved you a low number!
Try
www.Jegs.com
Jegs seem to have more Ford engine parts than Summit, but you can comparison shop both on line.
I have a geared starter, logo says "CVR" I think I got it from Jegs. Looks pretty much like the Tilton unit. Has worked fine for 13K, 5+ years.
Pete