Steve,
Since the ink was puddled and fresh I have a feeling that the cartridge was bad, but when I took it out it showed no ink anywhere on it and the other two were ok. And I have used that one before as I had three cartridges and you changed the 56 for a 59 when you were printing photos. Anyway I had expected to find at least one of the plastic gears with teeth worn or broken off but they all looked great. I have had other printers do much the same but could always find a reason. This was just strange and sounded as if you were grinding gears in a transmission and the paper would come out as if it had been pulled through sideways instead of straight. And I had already printed about 6 pictures before this happened, so something just gave up. As I said, it was an older printer and has had a ton of printing done with it. I really like the new all in one and the colors are better with the newer type ink.
Ron